UC students study political violence in America
For years, researchers looking to understand violent crimes motivated by ideology had to turn to data compiled by individual victim advocacy groups.
Now students at the University of Cincinnati are helping Assistant Professor Michael Loadenthal compile the largest database of its kind on political violence in the United States using records from state courts and the U.S. Department of Justice.
Assistant Professor Michael Loadenthal created the Prosecution Project to examine felony criminal cases related to political violence in the United States. Photo/Andrew Higley/UC Marketing + Brand
t’s a project Loadenthal created in 2017 while teaching a class on political violence at Miami University of Ohio. His students were looking to compare the sentences of white nationalists with left-wing defendants charged around the same time.
“Methodologically, the students weren’t able to find data that exists to make comparisons. Rather than continue to look for something that didn’t exist, we started constructing the data,” he said.
The idea, Loadenthal said, was to work on the data for a year and publish a paper on the numbers, but the project was so popular with students that they continued it.
Today, the database is called the Prosecution Project, a detailed collection of nearly 10,0000 cases of felony criminal cases dating back to 1990 spurred by motives that span the political and ideological spectrum.
Loadenthal said the database is helping researchers, politicians and even government agencies better understand the people who engage in political violence, the crimes they commit and the ways society punishes offenders.
On request, Loadenthal submitted expert testimony from the database to the U.S. House Select Committee Investigating the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol and shared the data set at political science conferences for the general public’s use.
Nobody wants to live in a violent place. Political violence has no place in America.
Madison Brown, UC College of Arts and Sciences student
The database has helped journalists put political events into historic and legal context, Loadenthal said. Some cable-television commentators have suggested that state and federal authorities ignored political violence spurred by the 2020 murder of George Floyd.
“When I hear that I want to throw the TV through the wall,” Loadenthal said.
His database shows that more than 1,700 defendants in those protests and riots have been charged with felonies. And that’s just the start of what can be gleaned from the database.
Most Americans no doubt recall the bombing of the USS Cole, the 1993 bombing of the World Trade Center and, of course, the 9/11 terror attacks on Washington and New York by al-Qaida. But the database identifies hundreds of other al-Qaida defendants convicted of unrelated criminal conspiracies and plots to harm Americans over the last 30 years.
The database also identifies defendants connected to hate groups, ecoterrorists, anti-fascists and abortion opponents charged with violent crimes.
The data isn’t predictive, Loadenthal said, but it is informative. Many criminal cases involve threats of harm to others, he said.
Students who take part on the project learn the ins and outs of courthouse databases to find information contained in criminal complaints, indictments, jury verdicts, plea deals and sentencings along with the skills needed to manage huge amounts of digital information.
Dozens of students scour court web portals such as Public Access to Court Electronic Records, or PACER, for relevant cases. Others upload data, while still others conduct audits of existing data to ensure accuracy, Loadenthal said.
Political science student Madison Brown began working on the database for her Honors Program research project. Now she volunteers to add trial updates gleaned from the court docket.
“I was a PACER newbie. I had never used it before, but I’m a master now,” she said. “I definitely think the Prosecution Project has taught me how to do valid research.”
Brown said she was surprised by how long it takes criminal cases to wind through state and federal courts. But she thinks the database provides invaluable context to understand political violence.
“Nobody wants to live in a violent place. Political violence has no place in America. But as long as the crimes happen, we’ll continue to track the cases,” Brown said.
Featured image at top: The Jan. 6th Committtee takes testimony on the 2020 attack on the U.S. Capitol. UC students have helped assemble a national database on felony criminal cases of political violence. Photo/House Select Committee
UC Assistant Professor Michael Loadenthal teaches political science in UC's School of Public and International Affairs. Photo/Andrew Higley/UC Marketing + Brand
Next Lives Here
The University of Cincinnati is leading public urban universities into a new era of innovation and impact. Our faculty, staff and students are saving lives, changing outcomes and bending the future in our city's direction. Next Lives Here.
Latest UC News
- UC Law hosted forum discussing election security, American democracy and civilityThe American Bar Association Task Force for American Democracy brought a host of speakers to the University of Cincinnati College of Law as part of a country-wide listening tour. Former Homeland Security Security Jeh Johnson was the event's keynote speaker. He highlighted the importance of election security and the need to protect American democracy.
- From scholarships to scalpelsIn her fourth year at the University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, Kamala Nelson is on the brink of realizing her dream of becoming a surgeon. But her path to this point has been anything but ordinary. It’s been a journey marked by rigorous academic challenges, a passion for helping underserved communities and — perhaps most crucially — the financial support of scholarships that made it all possible.
- UC grad fights for housing equality in CincinnatiLaTonya Springs has been around Cincinnati for a long time. A 2015 University of Cincinnati graduate, Springs has spent her time in and around Cincinnati, connecting with the people and learning about their lives and struggles, all with the hope of helping them fight for better conditions in the area. After starting her education, she was working full-time, which left her in a situation where finishing college didn’t make a lot of sense. However, once UC started a new program called Comeback Bearcat, Springs was able to come back and finish her undergraduate degree in communication, offered through the College of Arts and Sciences.
- Nominations open for All-University Faculty AwardsThe final nomination deadline for this year’s All-University Faculty Awards is Wednesday, November 20, 2024. In all, 12 different awards are offered through our 2024-25 All-University Faculty Awards competition.
- The multiple ways climate change threatens to make migraines worseThe University of Cincinnati's Vince Martin, MD, was featured in a Wired article discussing how climate change could worsen migraines.
- UC celebrates National Postdoc Appreciation WeekThe University of Cincinnati has a long list of events lined up to honor its postdoctoral fellows as colleges across the country celebrate National Postdoc Appreciation Week.