WVXU: Supreme Court temporarily blocks key air pollution regulations
Last week’s US Supreme Court decision, which temporarily blocked key air pollution regulations established by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), was just one in a line of recent rulings over the past two years significantly impacting the EPA’s authority to limit pollution in air and water. In last Thursday’s decision, the court ruled that the emissions-reductions standards set by the plan were likely to cause “irreparable harm” to almost half the states unless the court halted the rule pending further review by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia.
Cincinnati Law’s Professor Brad Mank spoke with WVXU about the impact of the most recent decision, stating that “The Ohio v. EPA decision will continue to worsen air quality, especially on the East Coast.
“In the short-term, this is a decision environmentalists won't like,” Mank said. “It's not good for the environment and it does show a kind of general trend that the current Supreme Court doesn't really like to give deference to agencies.”
About The Good Neighbor Plan
The EPA established the Good Neighbor Plan to ensure compliance with the 2015 Ozone National Ambient Air Quality Standards law. To carry out the law’s mandate, the EPA required “upwind” states to reduce air pollution affecting “downwind” states. Under the Good Neighbor rule, states are first given the chance to create a plan that complies with agency’s ozone guidelines. If a state fails to submit an adequate plan, the EPA then designs a compliance plan for the state. In February 2023, the EPA determined that 23 states had not provided sufficient plans and the agency then decided to implement its own emissions-control program for those states.
Ohio, along with several other states, large industrial companies, and trade associations, challenged the EPA plan in court. They contended that the agency’s “dictatorial approach” failed to adequately consider the legal and practical implications of substituting its own plan for the state plans. The opponents also argued that the plan’s implementation would cause significant economic and operational harm, particularly by forcing states to undertake costly modifications to their power plants while judicial review is pending in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia.
Read more about the decision, its impact, and Professor Mank’s commentary in the story “Supreme Court temporarily blocks key air pollution regulations".
Lead photo: istockphoto.com
Latest UC News
- Thinking globally: Developing an international nurse anesthesia partnershipThe desire to establish an international partnership has long been a goal of the University of Cincinnati (UC) College of Nursing Nurse Anesthesia DAs plans were placed on hold for a few years due to the COVID pandemic, virtual communications between the two institutions continued and, last April, six UC nursing students and two faculty members traveled to Paris, France, for a long-planned week of networking and education alongside IFITS students.octor of Nursing Practice program.
- Sculptor of Pete Rose statue talks about hit king's legacySpectrum News talks to University of Cincinnati graduate Tom Tsuchiya about his sculpture of baseball legend Pete Rose. The sculpture outside Great American Ball Park has become a memorial for Cincinnatians wishing to pay respects to the late World Series champion.
- Black girls face more frequent discipline in school, new report showsA new study from the U.S. Government Accountability Office shows Black girls face more frequent and severe discipline in public schools than girls from other racial backgrounds.
- Stroke symptoms for women to look out forThe University of Cincinnati's Pooja Khatri was featured in an MSN and Huffington Post UK article discussing how symptoms of stroke can look different for women.
- Study: Drug improves effectiveness of radiation for lung cancer that has spread to the brainThe University of Cincinnati’s Debanjan Bhattacharya is first author of new research published in Cancers that found the drug AM-101 improves the effectiveness and survival rate of radiation treatment in animal models of lung cancer that has spread to the brain.
- UC student leaders take a stand against gender-based violence with revival of music eventAfter a decade hiatus, the Clifton Heights Music Festival returns with more than 40 music acts set to perform Friday and Saturday, Oct. 4-5. UC students leaders have worked closely with presenter Far-i-Rome Creative to revive the festival.