Reporting on science in era of misinformation
Journalists and scientists sat down to discuss some of today’s most challenging issues: trust in science, information literacy, truth-telling, and the future of journalism.
The University of Cincinnati's Center for Public Engagement with Science recently hosted a panel discussion titled Reporting on Science in an Era of Misinformation moderated by UC College of Arts and Sciences Professor Jenny Wohlfarth.
The discussion brought together scientists and journalists to share their insights on how news media cover scientific topics in an era plagued with misinformation and disinformation.
“I’ve wanted to put together a discussion event like this for a while because it’s increasingly apparent how critically important science communication has become when there is so much misinformation and disinformation circulating online and all around us,” Wohlfarth said.
“As a journalist who has reported on scientific and environmental topics in my career, I know how helpful it is to find and interview scientists who are experts in their fields and are trying to help the public by sharing key information, insights and developments."
Wohlfarth said she wanted to bring together scientists and journalists to examine this challenge from each perspective and to discuss how both can do a better job to keep the public informed and engaged, and to earn back trust where it has been lost.
UC's Center for Public Engagement with Science hosted a panel discussion on science in an age of misinformation. Pictured from left are moderator and UC journalism Professor Jenny Wohlfarth, UC College of Engineering and Applied Science Associate Dean Whitney Gaskins, Local 12 journalist Duane Pohlman, UC Professor Amy Townsend-Small, SciLine producer Sara Whitlock and Cincinnati Enquirer data journalist Elizabeth B. Kim. Photo/Provided
Collaboration of science and news
The scientists on the panel included Whitney Gaskins, biomedical engineer and the associate dean of inclusive excellence, community engagement and faculty development in UC's College of Engineering and Applied Science, and UC Collegeof Arts and Sciences Professor Amy Townsend-Small, a researcher, teacher and mentor in environmental science and policy who teaches in the School of Environment and Sustainability.
The journalists included Elizabeth “Betsy” Kim, health and environment reporter at the Cincinnati Enquirer, Duane Pohlman, national investigative correspondent for “Spotlight on America” and chief investigative reporter and anchor for WKRC's Local 12, and Sara Whitlock, a biologist working at SciLine, a nonprofit organization based at the American Association for the Advancement of Science that helps connect journalists and scientists.
Lives are at stake when we don’t tell the truth about the impacts of science and technology on the world.
Whitney Gaskins, UC College of Engineering and Applied Science
Moderated by Wohlfarth with questions from the audience, the discussion examined the challenges of a changing media landscape.
“Newspapers are in the fight of their lives,” Pohlman said.
Newsrooms are shrinking while the classic newspaper is giving way to short and catchy news clips fit for social media consumption, he said.
“I wonder what it means for members of the public to figure out the truth when the internet incentivizes extremes and social media incentivizes the endless doom scroll, which is not a healthy way to consume information,” Kim said.
A major theme of the conversation was the importance of truth-telling.
“Lives are at stake when we don’t tell the truth about the impacts of science and technology on the world,” Gaskins said.
Despite a shared interest in telling the truth, differences in timelines can sometimes create a challenge for journalist and scientist collaboration. The journalists on the panel described the realities of quick turnarounds and looming deadlines.
“Journalists’ deadlines are often a few hours away and so they do not have the same timelines as scientists. Scientists sometimes don’t understand why journalists need to talk to them so quickly,” Whitlock said “Because science is a long and iterative process, it does not always fit into the news structure.”
Even responsible journalists who are dedicated to telling the truth about science sometimes find it difficult to do justice to complicated topics given the importance of timely reporting and limited newspaper space or broadcast time.
“Breaking news is king,” Pohlman noted.
Meanwhile, the average story in a broadcast newscast is 90 seconds.
Bloomberg News reporter Rachel Adams-Heard and UC Professor Amy Townsend-Small examine video of a natural gas leak captured by an infrared camera. Bloomberg turned to Townsend-Small to put its 2021 investigation of leaky oil wells into context for the public. Photo/Bloomberg News.
Risks of public engagement
Gaskins and Townsend-Small also described the ways in which, despite their passion for public engagement, they have been penalized for their outreach efforts.
“Universities need to do a better job at rewarding people that do public outreach,” Townsend-Small said. “The main way [academics] are rewarded is through journal articles and grants. Doing public outreach is not only not rewarded but thankless and even penalized. That needs to change.”
Both Gaskins and Townsend-Small have faced pushback and political fallout over their research efforts: Gaskins on diversifying engineering and Townsend-Small on investigating leaking wells in the oil and gas industries.
Despite these challenges, the panelists remain optimistic. They highlighted the importance and value of local resources such as libraries, fact-checking, and curiosity in increasing scientific literacy and combatting misinformation. All seemed to agree that we must continue to find ways to bring scientists and journalists into conversation with each other.
“For me, the discussion reinforced ideas and principles I hold very dear,” Wohlfarth said after the panel discussion.
“One, listen to experts. It’s perfectly okay to be skeptical about things, and we should all take the time to seek out reliable, ethical and unbiased source of scientific information — or any kind of information, for that matter — so that we can learn from experts who have spent years or decades researching the topics that have major impact in our lives.
“Two, support the public-serving institutions and organizations that strive to provide unbiased, ethical and trustworthy information to help us better understand, adapt to and survive in our world today. Those institutions include our local public libraries, our local news organizations, and non-profit and non-partisan newsrooms, within our communities and beyond, that are striving to keep the public well-informed about important issues relevant to our lives.”
Join UC's Center for Public Engagement with Science at more of its upcoming events.
Featured image at top: Misinformation is rampant on social media. UC hosted a panel discussion on ways scientists and the news media can fight it. Photo/iStockPhoto
Latest UC News
- UC named among nation's best schools for male nursing studentsThe University of Cincinnati (UC) College of Nursing has received the American Association for Men in Nursing (AAMN) 2024 Best Schools for Men in Nursing Award. A fourth-time award recipient, UC College of Nursing was unanimously approved for this honor and is one of only 17 schools of nursing nationwide honored for efforts to recruit and retain men in nursing.
- Trial finds new drug safe, effective to treat deadliest form of epilepsyThe University of Cincinnati’s Brandon Foreman, MD, presented Phase 3 clinical trial results at the Neurocritical Care Society’s 22nd Annual Meeting this week in San Diego, California that found ganaxolone is a safe and effective treatment for refractory status epilepticus.
- Data can help prevent housing crisesA University of Cincinnati professor and others are using data to identify people at risk of evictions and homelessness in order to intervene before a housing crisis occurs, Brick by Brick: Solutions for a Thriving Community reported.
- Lindner announces Applied AI LabThe Carl H. Lindner College of Business has formed the Applied AI Lab to ensure students, faculty, staff, partners and other valued college stakeholders can use the latest AI advances to solve real-world business problems.
- What is exoneration for individuals wrongly convicted of a crime?Tara Rosnell, chair of the Ohio Innocence Project's Board of Advocates, spoke recently with WYSO public radio station about how exoneration works for individuals wrongly convicted for crimes they did not commit. OIP at UC Law helped 42 people secure their freedom. The group of clients collectively spent more than 800 years behind bars for crimes they didn’t do.
- Fluency Friday supports teens, children who stutterA one-day workshop will bring together children and teens who stutter, offering an opportunity for them to connect while also giving parents and caregivers a chance to learn from experts on stuttering. Fluency Friday is hosted by the University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati Children’s Hospital, Hamilton County Educational Service Center and Pathways Forward Center for Stuttering.